I have this setting OFF
Enable strict oAuth
If on, the plugin will only connect users who are already logged into your WordPress website. If off, new accounts will be created automatically for users who are logging in for the first time via Patreon. Recommended: off
And I have this setting ON
Enable Login with Patreon
If on, users will be able to login to your website via Patreon and view patron only posts. If off, no one will be able to login to your website via Patreon and post locking will be disabled. Recommended: on
Is there a way to only allow login (and account creation) if they are already a paying Patron? I thought this was default behavior, but I see now that “Log In with Patreon” will create a new account for any user that connects their Patreon account even if they are not a paying Patron.
I can make changes to the plugin code directly if this is not possible through the settings. If you can point me in the right direction, it is much appreciated.