Here are the settings I have under the plugin:
Enable strict oAuth: Unchecked
Enable image locking features: Unchecked
Make entire site Patron-only with Pledge Level: Empty
Custom Call to Action Banner: Blank
Enable Login with Patreon: Checked
Allow Admins/Editors to ‘Login with Patreon’ Button: Unchecked
Custom Patreon Page name: Blank
Prevent caching of gated content: Yes
The active patron checkbox is unchecked and the first basic tier is selected.
One question - my Patreon is paused this month and set to resume in February. Does the plugin have some weird logic that makes it think everyone isn’t a patron due to them not being charged this month?
Otherwise, I’m at a loss.